Policy Statement & Disclaimer

Web Purebirth
The Pink Kit
The Pink Kit



The Safety of Childbirth

Safety in childbirth is measured by how many mothers and babies die and how many survive childbirth in less than perfect health. 

Studies done comparing hospital and out-of-hospital births indicate fewer deaths, injuries and infections for homebirths supervised by a trained attendant than for hospital births. No such studies indicate that hospitals have better outcomes than homebirths. 

So what of unassisted births? No official studies have been done to date yet on this.

Purebirth Australia is currently (as of July 2006) conducting a collection of unassisted childbirth data from Australian women. The Australian Unassisted Childbirth Statistics page will be updated as data comes in.

You can see unofficial unassisted childbirth stats here at the Centre for Unhindered Living.

Also Laura Shanley passed the following stats for unassisted birth:

Intended UCs March 1999-March 2000
Total: 54 babies
8 born in the hospital (one was a C-section)
2 born at home with a midwife
44 born at home unassisted

The 8 women who went to the hospital said they essentially went due to fear, pain, or lack of support from their husbands. One woman was losing her vision and thought it best to go.

The C-section was a breech. The woman went because she was in a lot of pain. The doctor gave her the option of either a vaginal birth or C-sec and she chose the C-sec.

The 2 women who called midwives were a little nervous during the birth. Both their midwives were very good, and non-interventive.

With the UCs, there were 2 transfers after the birth. One woman was losing too much blood (VBAC), the other gave birth prematurely and thought it best to take the baby to the hospital.

Both women were happy they had had a UC, as were the other 42. So the outcomes were very good. These stats are from all the women who have contacted me in the past year and said they were intending to have a UC.

 

bar

Childbirth and the Car Analogy

So you want to know how safe childbirth is really?

Let's look at the cultural conditioning of what childbirth is believed to be.

Most births take place in hospitals today and many people say that they had birth complications and that 'things had to be done' to assist in birthing. They take this to mean childbirth is inherently risky, and to give birth is safe if you do it in hospital with medical assistance at the ready.

That however, is not indicative of real physiological childbirth. Birth in the medical model, especially in hospital, is anything BUT natural or as Nature intended.

Birth works but the interference has already begun long before the interventions of birth occur.

Interference in the form of our belief structures, the accepted 'facts and norms' of society simply because it is that way for many, many people, the mass media, our cultures, our upbringing, our fears and even our less than optimal lifestyles.

If you want birth to be safe, there are many factors to consider, the most important being the trust and guidance of your instincts.

Just like gaining confidence to drive a car safely through learning, education (both external and self), instinct, reflexes, experience etc, you can also gain confidence that you can birth safely.

It is all within your reach if you so desire it.

If you want to keep going along the track of thought in comparing birthing with driving a car; consider this:

Birthing is a natural physiological process, designed by millions of years of evolution.

Driving a car is not. Technically, it could be considered an unnatural form of transport that came about with advances in civilisation. As for modern childbirth as opposed to physiological childbirth, the more our civilisation has advanced medically, the further it has gone off track from what childbirth really is.

Birthing as we were designed to birth, is safe. True risks, deaths or unresolvable complications ARE rare. Eg. Extremely short cords preventing baby from descending, complete true placenta previa, etc are rare.

Placenta previa and accreta are becoming less rare due to scars in the uterus from increased c-sections today. We are hearing about more and more complications of childbirth that have nothing to do with the risks of physiological childbirth and everything to do with the risks of hindering physiological childbirth.

Driving a car, as it was meant to be driven, is not as safe as giving birth as birth was meant to be given.

True risks, deaths or unresolvable complications ARE NOT rare in driving a car. Why? Because you can't control what other people do in their own cars. You could be the world's safest driver, yet be hit and killed by some speeding idiot.

Likewise, giving birth in an environment where you are subject to unnatural hindrances and influences on your birth is a car accident waiting to happen, especially if you opt to give birth as you were NOT meant to - under the influence of drugs, with instruments, observation, sterility and stress.

Medical technology and assistance has its place in emergencies and in rare complications of physiological childbirth, but does little to safeguard childbirth itself from complications.

 

About Us | Site Map | Policy Statement & Disclaimer | Contact Us | ©2006 Purebirth Australia